The demand for probiotics, or good bacteria, products has surged globally and in the UK over the past 10 years. These trends have occurred despite lack of conclusive scientific evidence on the health benefits of probiotic products and regulatory clampdowns on health claims on product labels. Our project sought to ask a simple, but important question: how can we explain consumer confidence in probiotics products despite the contradictory scientific evidence and regulatory controversies?
Approach
Our approach to examining this question was driven by previous research findings which suggest that:
- consumer’s dietary choices are driven by a range of psychological factors,
- consumers obtain information about nutritional information from multiple sources,
- analyzing social media data can offer useful insights into consumer behaviors and sentiments related to nutrition.
Applying these insights to our question, we carried out a series of three research studies:
- a survey of consumers in England, Scotland and Wales to identify psychological factors and informational sources that influence probiotics consumption and confidence,
- analysis of five years of Twitter data to identify the significant themes that drove these conversations
- an analysis of interactions between different kinds of communities in the Twitter network to examine the relative influence of these communities on the conversations.
Preliminary findings
Our preliminary findings suggest that the global sentiment surrounding probiotics has been progressively positive over the past 10 years.
In the UK, consumers are highly confident about probiotics products being beneficial for their health but are skeptical of the safety of these products. Health was also the main theme that shaped Twitter chatter on probiotics over the past five years.
Furthermore, we learned that consumers place most trust in scientists and least in journalists in terms of their ability to provide authentic information about probiotics. However, the scientific community exerted the least amount of influence on Twitter where the probiotics industry (promoters, manufacturers and marketers) were found to bear the strongest influence.
Engaging the public
Our project included various initiatives to engage the public in the scientific conversation about probiotics, and also disseminating the findings of our scientific research to non-scientific audiences. These initiatives included a series of theatre workshops with school children, a blog, a series of short podcasts, and an infographic series, all of which are available on projectgutfeel.com
Research Team
- Dr Santosh Vijay Kumar – Department of Psychology, Northumbria University
- Dr Pamela Graham, Department of Social Work, Northumbria University
- Dr Seraphim Alvanides, Department of Architecture and Built Environment, Northumbria University
- Dr Kristofor McCarty, Department of Psychology, Northumbria University
- Ms Cyndy Au, Regional Director, DuPont Nutrition and Health